Change Healthcare attack expected to exceed USD 1 billion in costs

The Change Healthcare cyberattack places the survival of many healthcare practices at risk due to delays in patient care and reimbursement. The incident has led to massive repercussions across the U.S. healthcare industry.

“The cyber impacts in the quarter totaled about USD 870 million,” said John Rex, President and Chief Financial Officer of UnitedHealth Group at the recent earnings call.

“Of the USD 870 million, about USD 595 million were direct costs due to the clearinghouse platform restoration and other response efforts, including medical expenses directly relating to the temporary suspension of some care management activities. For the full year, we estimate these direct costs at USD 1 billion to USD 1.15 billion,” Rex continued.

Part of the costs of the Change Healthcare incident include a payout of more than USD 2 billion to help healthcare providers who have been affected by the cyberattack. However, this may not be enough to help some practices reeling from the impact.

A survey conducted by the American Medical Association (AMA) showed the extent of the damage. In percentage of surveyed practices affected:

• 36% have seen claims payments suspended
• 32% have not been able to submit claims
• 77% of respondents said they experienced service disruptions
• 80% of providers said they lost revenue from unpaid claims
• 78% lost revenue from claims that they have been unable to submit
• 55% have used personal funds to cover expenses incurred as a result of the attack

In the survey, some practitioners shared their pain in words, in comments such as “This cyberattack is leading me to bankruptcy, and I am just about out of cash.” Other respondents said, “This crippled our brand new practice. I am keeping the lights on using personal funds.” Another practitioner said that the incident may bankrupt their “practice of 50 years” in a rural community.

While not specifically mentioned in the UnitedHealth Group earnings call, the legal fees associated with the hack will be steep. To soften the blow, Change Healthcare wants to consolidate 24 class-action lawsuits, according to a recent court filing.

The UnitedHealth Group subsidiary asked a judicial panel to combine the suits and centralize them in the federal U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee — where Change Healthcare is headquartered. The company argues that the cases share factual and legal claims and that consolidating would preserve court resources.

If the first hack wasn’t bad enough, fresh reports have surfaced that Change Healthcare is being extorted again by another group called RansomHub. Multi-phase extortion ransomware attacks like this are all too common as intruders attempt to double down on their demands.

In this case, the second extortion appears to be an ALPHV affiliate that likely participated in a Ransomware-as-a-Service type of scheme where multiple actors participate in the attack. Leaked screenshots appear to show Change Healthcare data and files, including patient data. The group states it will sell the stolen data to the highest bidder if Change Healthcare refuses to negotiate payment.

It’s not clear if this second extortion attempt was included in the cost analysis. Either way, the Change Healthcare attack will go down in history as one of the most costly data breaches ever. As Congress members wrote, “The breach of Change was tantamount to targeting the health care system in its entirety.”