August 28, 2017 By Larry Loeb 2 min read

This week, the National Infrastructure Advisory Council (NIAC) published a draft report detailing industry and government strategies that will reduce the complex risks associated with critical infrastructure sectors. The report, “Securing Cyber Assets: Addressing Urgent Cyber Threats to Critical Infrastructure,” continued the work of the council, which was first appointed by former President George W. Bush in 2001 to advise the U.S. president on the cybersecurity of critical services.

The Government Is Falling Short

The draft report warned that the country is falling short on its ability to defend critical systems against aggressive cyberattacks. In it, the council asserted that the country is at pre-9/11 cybersecurity and there is only a narrow window of opportunity yet available to coordinate resources.

The NIAC made 11 specific recommendations in the report to shore up the country’s cybersecurity defenses. Among these are the establishment of specific network paths designated for the most critical networks, which would include dark fiber networks for critical control system traffic and reserved spectrum for backup communications during emergencies.

Authors of the report also advised improved threat information sharing between private and government bodies, with the government providing incentives for any hardware upgrades performed.

Private Sector Response to Cybersecurity Advice

SecurityWeek talked to a number of private sector leaders who were less than enthusiastic about the report and its recommendations.

Sqrrl director Matt Zanderigo noted that the NIAC’s recommendations were all voluntary, although they had incentives. He said that the national effect of an attack on critical infrastructure targets would be far greater than the impact on a single operator. Zanderigo believed that this mismatch between local and national risk is a type of market inefficiency that is typically best filled by regulation, not by voluntary efforts.

Chris Roberts, chief security architect at Acalvio, also expressed concern with the recommendations. “Frankly, 11 key recommendations are about five too many,” he told SecurityWeek. He added that private industry needs to share threat information among itself better than it currently does, and the government needs to share its intelligence with the private sector.

In short, the NIAC report didn’t give enough new information. Not only that, but its voluntary recommendations will likely be ignored because they are not practical for most businesses. However, one of its most important takeaways is that a cohesive and collaborative approach from both government and private sectors will be necessary to protect the critical infrastructure that remains vulnerable in the U.S.

More from

Cyberattack on American Water: A warning to critical infrastructure

3 min read - American Water, the largest publicly traded United States water and wastewater utility, recently experienced a cybersecurity incident that forced the company to disconnect key systems, including its customer billing platform. As the company’s investigation continues, there are growing concerns about the vulnerabilities that persist in the water sector, which has increasingly become a target for cyberattacks. The breach is a stark reminder of the critical infrastructure risks that have long plagued the industry. While the water utility has confirmed that…

What’s behind unchecked CVE proliferation, and what to do about it

4 min read - The volume of Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVEs) has reached staggering levels, placing immense pressure on organizations' cyber defenses. According to SecurityScorecard, there were 29,000 vulnerabilities recorded in 2023, and by mid-2024, nearly 27,500 had already been identified.Meanwhile, Coalition's 2024 Cyber Threat Index forecasts that the total number of CVEs for 2024 will hit 34,888—a 25% increase compared to the previous year. This upward trend presents a significant challenge for organizations trying to manage vulnerabilities and mitigate potential exploits.What’s behind…

Quishing: A growing threat hiding in plain sight

4 min read - Our mobile devices go everywhere we go, and we can use them for almost anything. For businesses, the accessibility of mobile devices has also made it easier to create more interactive ways to introduce new products and services while improving user experiences across different industries. Quick-response (QR) codes are a good example of this in action and help mobile devices quickly navigate to web pages or install new software by simply scanning an image.However, legitimate organizations aren’t the only ones…

Topic updates

Get email updates and stay ahead of the latest threats to the security landscape, thought leadership and research.
Subscribe today