March 14, 2017 By Douglas Bonderud 2 min read

Data is a valuable resource for corporations. Beyond the information generated by workstations, mobile devices and online transactions, companies now leverage social data to get a better sense of consumer buying habits, personal preferences and transaction histories.

But in many cases, the nature and purpose of this data collection isn’t made clear — and law enforcement agencies are now tapping third party data-mining operations to purchase specific data related to potentially criminal activity and design surveillance tools.

It’s no surprise that Facebook ranks among the most sought-after data destinations. According to TechCrunch, the company recently changed its policy to explicitly forbid developers from using social media data for this purpose. But will this really put the breaks on sneaky surveillance operations?

Social Data Is All Around

Corporations have the power to hurt or help consumers who want better protection of their own data. Law enforcement agencies don’t need custom-built tools to carry out surveillance; mobile apps often collect and aggregate consumer data that is then sold off to marketing agencies and could be used for other purposes as well.

Direct law enforcement requests are also on the rise. In February, the Bentonville, Arkansas, Police Department went after a warrant for Amazon Echo interactions initiated by a murder suspect. Additionally, the Financial Times stated more than 200 million wearable devices were provided to employees by their organizations in 2016, often without any kind of user agreement about how, when and why tracking data could be shared.

Line in the Sand

Part of the problem here stems from consumers themselves, since many grant blanket permissions to mobile apps and don’t read user agreements before they sign off on wearable devices. But there’s another layer: Anonymous collection of data that is then repackaged and repurposed as valuable insight for marketing or police agencies.

Facebook, Twitter and other social sites are a veritable gold mine of information for third parties looking to grab information and make a quick buck. Engadget explained the ACLU recently called out both Facebook and Twitter for not doing enough to combat this problem. Both sites were being mined for information about protesters’ posts, locations and identification by marketing firms and then sold off to law enforcement.

While Twitter already has a hard-and-fast rule in place, Facebook historically operated under a “wait and see” model — if problems were reported, the company clamped down on social data access. But thanks to increased pressure from the ACLU, Color of Change and the Center for Media Justice, the network has rewritten its policies to make it clear that developers cannot “use data obtained from us to provide tools that are used for surveillance,” The New York Times reported.

Moving Forward

It’s a solid first step, but now the real test begins: Will action follow words? While Facebook already uses manual and automatic detection to track down unsanctioned data use, the ACLU argued a more proactive approach is required. The social media site countered that it’s already doing just that, meaning there may be little impetus for change.

Social pressure has pushed one of the biggest social media sites in the world to explicitly forbid the use of data for surveillance tools. It’s a timely move since smartphones, wearables and other mobile devices are now being used to track everything from employee activity to protester activism.

With the change, however, comes increased surveillance of the social site itself — will it shine a light on surreptitious data collection or turn a blind eye when it comes to stopping surveillance?

More from

How to craft a comprehensive data cleanliness policy

3 min read - Practicing good data hygiene is critical for today’s businesses. With everything from operational efficiency to cybersecurity readiness relying on the integrity of stored data, having confidence in your organization’s data cleanliness policy is essential.But what does this involve, and how can you ensure your data cleanliness policy checks the right boxes? Luckily, there are practical steps you can follow to ensure data accuracy while mitigating the security and compliance risks that come with poor data hygiene.Understanding the 6 dimensions of…

2024 roundup: Top data breach stories and industry trends

3 min read - With 2025 on the horizon, it’s important to reflect on the developments and various setbacks that happened in cybersecurity this past year. While there have been many improvements in security technologies and growing awareness of emerging cybersecurity threats, 2024 was also a hard reminder that the ongoing fight against cyber criminals is far from over.We've summarized this past year's top five data breach stories and industry trends, with key takeaways from each that organizations should note going into the following…

Black Friday chaos: The return of Gozi malware

4 min read - On November 29th, 2024, Black Friday, shoppers flooded online stores to grab the best deals of the year. But while consumers were busy filling their carts, cyber criminals were also seizing the opportunity to exploit the shopping frenzy. Our system detected a significant surge in Gozi malware activity, targeting financial institutions across North America. The Black Friday connection Black Friday creates an ideal environment for cyber criminals to thrive. The combination of skyrocketing transaction volumes, a surge in online activity…

Topic updates

Get email updates and stay ahead of the latest threats to the security landscape, thought leadership and research.
Subscribe today