U.S. cybersecurity recruiting and retention practices need an overhaul. That’s the takeaway from a new report by Department of Commerce (DoC) and Department of Homeland Security (DHS), which noted that “the United States needs immediate and sustained improvements in its cybersecurity workforce situation.”

What’s more, a recent review by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) asserted that “agencies do not understand and do not have the resources to combat the current threat environment.” In other words, national cybersecurity practices aren’t keeping pace with rapidly evolving cyberthreats — and that means rising risk for federal information security.

The IT Skills Gap Impedes Government Cybersecurity

The DoC/DHS report was commissioned last year as part of the White House’s “Presidential Executive Order on Strengthening the Cybersecurity of Federal Networks and Critical Infrastructure.” Specifically, the document tasked both departments with assessing the scope and efficiency of efforts to train the next generation of cybersecurity workers and creating a report that detailed both data findings and recommendations to improve the federal cybersecurity outlook.

According to the new report, there’s an estimated 299,000 shortfall in cybersecurity professionals to available jobs and intense competition for talented candidates across all industry sectors. Positions range from front-line support, which requires minimal credentials, to advanced careers demanding multiple degrees and certifications.

In addition, the report found that the federal government “depends heavily on its cybersecurity workforce, supplemented by contractors.” Since “the majority of critical infrastructure is owned and operated by private companies,” however, any shortfall in U.S. cybersecurity poses commensurate risks for national security.

In addition, despite the “general context and urgency of the situation,” lengthy security clearance delays and onboarding processes, coupled with a knowledge gap about specific workforce needs and education programs, also impact total cybersecurity numbers across the country.

Strengthening the Cybersecurity Workforce

The report recommended tapping traditionally under-represented groups, such as women, minorities and military veterans, for cybersecurity positions.

Pay is also a problem: The report found that while compensation for cybersecurity jobs is above average levels in the private sector, “cybersecurity pay is below the level needed to attract the necessary talent.” As a result, the DHS and DoC called for new funding priorities to create high-quality cybersecurity education and workforce development programs.

In addition, the report recommended “a high-profile national Call to Action to draw attention to and mobilize public and private sector resources to address cybersecurity workforce needs” and encouraged both the public and private sectors to align education and training with employers’ current priorities.

Finally, the report revealed a need to reskill current employees and displaced workers to take on cybersecurity roles rather than looking for outside talent — especially given the widening skills gap, which is on track to reach a cybersecurity workforce shortage of 1.8 million in less than four years, according to Frost and Sullivan.

Cybersecurity is now a national priority. The DHS/DoC report described key stumbling blocks, made critical recommendations and laid out a clear mandate: “The federal government must lead in the effort to close U.S. cybersecurity workforce gaps — something that can be achieved only by changing the way the country views and practices cybersecurity.”

More from

Most organizations want security vendor consolidation

4 min read - Cybersecurity is complicated, to say the least. Maintaining a strong security posture goes far beyond knowing about attack groups and their devious TTPs. Merely understanding, coordinating and unifying security tools can be challenging.We quickly passed through the “not if, but when” stage of cyberattacks. Now, it’s commonplace for companies to have experienced multiple breaches. Today, cybersecurity has taken a seat in core business strategy discussions as the risks and costs have risen dramatically.For this reason, 75% of organizations seek to…

How IBM secures the U.S. Open

2 min read - More than 15 million tennis fans around the world visited the US Open app and website this year, checking scores, poring over statistics and watching highlights from hundreds of matches over the two weeks of the tournament. To help develop this world-class digital experience, IBM Consulting worked closely with the USTA, developing powerful generative AI models that transform tennis data into insights and original content. Using IBM watsonx, a next-generation AI and data platform, the team built and managed the entire…

How the FBI Fights Back Against Worldwide Cyberattacks

5 min read - In the worldwide battle against malicious cyberattacks, there is no organization more central to the fight than the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). And recent years have proven that the bureau still has some surprises up its sleeve. In early May, the U.S. Department of Justice announced the conclusion of a U.S. government operation called MEDUSA. The operation disrupted a global peer-to-peer network of computers compromised by malware called Snake. Attributed to a unit of the Russian government Security Service,…

How NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 Tackles Risk Management

4 min read - The NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 (CSF) is moving into its final stages before its 2024 implementation. After the public discussion period to inform decisions for the framework closed in May, it’s time to learn more about what to expect from the changes to the guidelines. The updated CSF is being aligned with the Biden Administration’s National Cybersecurity Strategy, according to Cherilyn Pascoe, senior technology policy advisor with NIST, at the 2023 RSA Conference. This sets up the new CSF to…