The idea is a good one: Use the cellphone camera to take a selfie and employ it as another login authentication credential.

Say Cheese

Both MasterCard and LogMeOnce have introduced a type of selfie authentication. The MasterCard process is very straightforward: If someone is buying a product from a participating merchant, the customer will get a push notification to the mobile device, which opens the selfie authentication app.

Users are then asked to blink (to show that they are living people and not just holding up a photo) and snap a picture. The app compares the photos taken to the one submitted by customers at the time of registration to verify their identity. The purchase is then approved and completed.

MasterCard announced its app last fall. Another vendor, LogMeOnce, recently added selfie authentication to its multifactor authentication service. LogMeOnce claims several hundred apps are already supported with the process. They rely on the end user verifying the photo on their mobile device — you can swipe right and left to see GPS and IP address details for further confirmation of your identity — and then use the photo as a master password to unlock your password vault.

Eliminating Authentication Weaknesses

Why are these tools important? There are weaknesses in all kinds of one-time passwords, including any selfie authentication. These weaknesses have been known and exploited for years: An attacker swaps the ever-changing part of the authentication process (the photo or the changing series of digits generated by a one-time password server) with something that appears to be dynamic but isn’t.

Security analyst Bruce Schneier addressed one such attack back in 2009. “We have to stop trying to authenticate the person; instead, we need to authenticate the transaction,” he wrote. “The current wave of attacks against financial systems are not exploiting vulnerabilities in the authentication system, so two-factor authentication doesn’t help.”

Indeed, there are still issues today. Wired published a scare story about not using SMS texts as the additional factor because of potential man-in-the-middle (MitM) attacks. The additional authentication factor “isn’t an invincibility spell. Especially if that second factor is delivered via text message,” Wired stated. “For services like Twitter that only offer second factor protections that depend on SMS, it’s time to wake up, smell the targeted attacks and give users better options.”

Wired cited the case of one well-known community organizer who had his Twitter account taken over. The attacker intercepted the one-time authentication codes by impersonating the victim and convincing the carrier to forward the text messages.

Is Selfie Authentication the Future?

Clearly, we need better authentication tools to manage the many passwords we amass as we use more and more online services. A number of vendors are working on other mechanisms besides selfies, such as PasswordlessApps’ Tidas project. This service uses the private encryption keys inside the more recent iPhones to sign and encrypt your data.

Its software development kit requires only a fingerprint and the TouchID button on the phone to login — no password required whatsoever. This is a great idea, since all private information is stored inside the iPhone and nothing is transmitted anywhere else.

This is only the first step in the path toward better authentication measures.

More from Identity & Access

Kronos Malware Reemerges with Increased Functionality

The Evolution of Kronos Malware The Kronos malware is believed to have originated from the leaked source code of the Zeus malware, which was sold on the Russian underground in 2011. Kronos continued to evolve and a new variant of Kronos emerged in 2014 and was reportedly sold on the darknet for approximately $7,000. Kronos is typically used to download other malware and has historically been used by threat actors to deliver different types of malware to victims. After remaining…

An IBM Hacker Breaks Down High-Profile Attacks

On September 19, 2022, an 18-year-old cyberattacker known as "teapotuberhacker" (aka TeaPot) allegedly breached the Slack messages of game developer Rockstar Games. Using this access, they pilfered over 90 videos of the upcoming Grand Theft Auto VI game. They then posted those videos on the fan website GTAForums.com. Gamers got an unsanctioned sneak peek of game footage, characters, plot points and other critical details. It was a game developer's worst nightmare. In addition, the malicious actor claimed responsibility for a…

What is the Future of Password Managers?

In November 2022, LastPass had its second security breach in four months. Although company CEO Karim Toubba assured customers they had nothing to worry about, the incident didn’t inspire confidence in the world’s leading password manager application. Password managers have one vital job: keep your sensitive login credentials secret, so your accounts remain secure. When hackers compromise these software applications, the entire industry of identity and access management (IAM) takes notice. As an alliance of tech giants leads a global push…

Beware of What Is Lurking in the Shadows of Your IT

This post was written with contributions from Joseph Lozowski. Comprehensive incident preparedness requires building out and testing response plans that consider the possibility that threats will bypass all security protections. An example of a threat vector that can bypass security protections is “shadow IT” and it is one that organizations must prepare for. Shadow IT is the use of any hardware or software operating within an enterprise without the knowledge or permission of IT or Security. IBM Security X-Force responds…