Public Key Infrastructure Concerns Raise Questions Over Internet Authentication System
Malware creators are abusing the code-signing process associated with public key infrastructure (PKI), and their actions are a considerable threat to internet authentication systems.
At the recent ACM Conference on Computer and Communications Security in Dallas, security researchers from the University of Maryland highlighted potential problems in the code-signing approach used in PKI. These flaws affect some products created by antivirus firms and could create significant issues for businesses that rely on PKI for authentication.
The Problem With Public Key Infrastructure
The researchers analyzed more than 150,000 malware samples from a 2014 data set and discovered 325 samples that either held a valid, revoked or malformed certificate. In the report, they noted that digitally signed malware can sidestep the protection mechanisms that ensure programs are only launched when they have valid signatures. Such malware can also dodge sophisticated antivirus technologies.
They concluded that exploitation focuses on three kinds of flaws in the code-signing PKI: publisher-side key mishandling, insufficient client-side safeguards of certificates and certificate authority-side confirmation breakdowns.
When it comes to publisher-side issues, they discovered 72 compromised certificates within 325 malware samples. Five of the eight publishers who were subsequently contacted about the issues were unaware of the problematic certification and potential exploitation.
Worse still, two-thirds of malware samples signed with these 72 compromised certificates are still effective, according to the report. In these instances, the signature check does not produce any errors and could provide a means for threat actors to bypass system protection measures.
In fact, malware creators might not even require the power of a code-signing certificate. The paper noted that flaw in 34 antivirus products allowed fraudsters to copy signatures from a legitimate file to a known malware sample without being detected.
The researchers disclosed the problem to antivirus companies, two of which confirmed that their products failed to check the signature properly. One vendor announced plans to fix the issue.
PKI Problems Getting Progressively Worse
Doowon Kim, one of the researchers involved in the project, told Threatpost that problems with code signing are systemic and PKI abuses are becoming progressively worse. He noted that 80 percent of exploited certificates are still a threat six years after being originally used to sign malware.
The Cyber Security Research Institute recently discovered that threat actors can purchase code-signing certificates on the Dark Web for $1,200, Beta News reported. Peter Warren, chairman of CSRI, said that the criminal market for certificates casts doubt over the entire authentication system for the internet.
With the threat level rising and compromised certificates readily available to fraudsters, these code-signing concerns pose a serious threat to businesses that rely on public key infrastructure.