According to the 2014 IBM Chief Information Security Officer Assessment, 95 percent of information security incidents involve human error. Human error is not only the most important factor affecting security, but it is also a key factor in aviation accidents and in medical errors. Information security risk managers and chief information security officers can benefit from the insights of studies on the human factor within these industries to reduce human error related to security.

What Is Human Error?

Human errors are usually defined as circumstances in which planned actions, decisions or behaviors reduce — or have the potential to reduce — quality, safety and security. Examples of human error involved in information security include the following:

  • System misconfiguration;
  • Poor patch management;
  • Use of default usernames and passwords or easy-to-guess passwords;
  • Lost devices;
  • Disclosure of information via an incorrect email address;
  • Double-clicking on an unsafe URL or attachment;
  • Sharing passwords with others;
  • Leaving computers unattended when outside the workplace;
  • Using personally owned mobile devices that connect to the organization’s network.

Human-factor engineers in aviation assume that serious incidents are not caused by just one human error, but by an unfortunate alignment of several individual events. Incidents happen when a series of minor events occur consecutively and/or concurrently. It is easy to see the parallel with information security incidents, which are often caused by a combination of human errors and security inadequacies.

Strategies to Tackle Human Error

Organizations apply a variety of strategies to secure information. Many of these are based on lessons from the human-factor engineering discipline. Some well-known examples include the following:

  1. Eliminating strategies that make it possible for system users to make a mistake. For example, you could use automated safeguards such as cryptography, password management, identity and access management, network access rules and automatic standby locks.
  2. Using prevention strategy approaches to support someone in the correct execution of tasks, such as checklists, awareness campaigns, procedures, disciplinary measures, litigation threats, training and retraining.
  3. Using a mitigation strategy to mitigate the consequences of errors by making sure detection mechanisms are in place to correct situations before they become an incident. Examples include audits, internal control, breach detection solutions, system monitoring and surveillance.

Developing Helpful Programs

Additionally, the aviation and health care industries support a holistic error prevention approach to change conditions in the organization, the environment and the systems that people work with. These systemic (socio-technical) strategies could be of great benefit to information security.

Crew resource management (CRM) is a training program developed for airline crews to learn how to manage and behave during an incident. CRM training encompasses communication, situational awareness, problem-solving, decision-making and teamwork. The application of CRM in health care and aviation has proven to significantly reduce errors. When applying this method to information security, it is important to recognize that humans are your strongest links in times of crisis. Security incidents will happen, and staff should be trained to recognize and contain them. Rehearsing possible incident scenarios with your team and taking time to imagine other risks will prepare the team for possible scenarios. In the case of an ongoing data breach, staff will be prepared to make the best possible use of equipment, procedures and each other.

Decades’ worth of data from aviation incident reporting systems have been effectively used to redesign aircraft, air traffic control systems, airports and pilot training. Information security specialists should also keep analyzing security incidents and near misses. Without such analysis, there is no way to uncover recurring errors. Investigations should target the people involved, the team, the workplace, the organization, third parties and the information and communications technology systems. The important issue is not who blundered, but how and why the incident occurred.

It has long been recognized that distractions, fatigue, workload, poor environmental conditions and poor system and process design influence the number of medical errors. These factors should also be included in information security risk assessments. For example, overworked staff members are more likely to deviate from the expected security behavior.

Finally, leadership is essential to change the conditions in which you work. Local “champions” (security officers, auditors, data protection officers, compliance officers, crisis managers, etc.) can motivate others, but major changes toward a secure and resilient organization require technological investment, direction and support from the leaders who demonstrate their own commitment to information security.

It is human to make errors, and they can never be 100 percent prevented. A mixture of strategies may help to prevent human errors from turning into security incidents. Successes in human error reduction in aviation give hope, while studies of medical errors provide valuable insight. Information security can improve greatly when you keep learning from other sectors and collaborate to share knowledge.

More from CISO

Who Carries the Weight of a Cyberattack?

Almost immediately after a company discovers a data breach, the finger-pointing begins. Who is to blame? Most often, it is the chief information security officer (CISO) or chief security officer (CSO) because protecting the network infrastructure is their job. Heck, it is even in their job title: they are the security officer. Security is their responsibility. But is that fair – or even right? After all, the most common sources of data breaches and other cyber incidents are situations caused…

Transitioning to Quantum-Safe Encryption

With their vast increase in computing power, quantum computers promise to revolutionize many fields. Artificial intelligence, medicine and space exploration all benefit from this technological leap — but that power is also a double-edged sword. The risk is that threat actors could abuse quantum computers to break the key cryptographic algorithms we depend upon for the safety of our digital world. This poses a threat to a wide range of critical areas. Fortunately, alternate cryptographic algorithms that are safe against…

How Do You Plan to Celebrate National Computer Security Day?

In October 2022, the world marked the 19th Cybersecurity Awareness Month. October might be over, but employers can still talk about awareness of digital threats. We all have another chance before then: National Computer Security Day. The History of National Computer Security Day The origins of National Computer Security Day trace back to 1988 and the Washington, D.C. chapter of the Association for Computing Machinery’s Special Interest Group on Security, Audit and Control. As noted by National Today, those in…

Emotional Blowback: Dealing With Post-Incident Stress

Cyberattacks are on the rise as adversaries find new ways of creating chaos and increasing profits. Attacks evolve constantly and often involve real-world consequences. The growing criminal Software-as-a-Service enterprise puts ready-made tools in the hands of threat actors who can use them against the software supply chain and other critical systems. And then there's the threat of nation-state attacks, with major incidents reported every month and no sign of them slowing. Amidst these growing concerns, cybersecurity professionals continue to report…